10 Vintage Sauces That Bring the Best Old-Timey Flavor

Author amortownship Reading 4 min Views 4 Published by May 9, 2025

Credit:

Dotdash Meredith Food Studios

The secret to many recipes lies in the sauce. Whether you’re grilling a burger or making pasta from scratch, sauce plays a big role in tying flavors together. If you’re in search of a way to bring an extra boost of flavor to your meal, try a sauce that deserves a comeback. We’ve collected 10 vintage sauces that got their start back in the day but still deserve plenty of attention. These are old-fashioned recipes you didn’t know you needed, whether you need a classic garnish for a hot dog or something simple for dipping.

01
of 10

Grandpa's Classic Coney Sauce

“Coney sauce is a condiment of ground beef simmered in tangy flavors and served on hot dogs,” says recipe creator Sean S. “My grandfather owned a drive-in restaurant back in the 1950s. This is his exact recipe for Coney dogs from back in the day. I make this on special occasions, and it is always hit with friends and family.”

View Recipe

Save

02
of 10

Grammy Faith's Mustard Sauce

"A creamy mustard sauce with a rich texture that is perfect with pork," says Allrecipes member LIBIS. "We have always used this on ham with our Christmas dinners…a family favorite, and one of the only 'family recipes' we have."

View Recipe

Save

03
of 10

Old Fashioned Sicilian Succo

MOLLE888

"My Nana used to cook this for me when I was young and as she prepared things and we waited for the sauce to finish, she'd tell me great stories about her life in Sicily and other secret business," says Allrecipes member Joiamia. "This recipe is the best sauce I've ever had—I really think it can bring the family together."

View Recipe

Save

20 Italian Recipes You’ve Probably Never Tried

04
of 10

Old Style BBQ Sauce

"Great sauce! The slow cooker makes it easy to make and convenient," says reviewer ANGELGIRL94. "I ate it on everything from meats to sandwiches to scrambled eggs. This recipe's a winner!"

View Recipe

Save

05
of 10

Peg's Meatloaf Sauce

fabeveryday

“This was a great easy meatloaf sauce! It’s a sweeter sauce,” says Allrecipes Allstar fabeveryday. “I was surprised about the use of nutmeg, but found that it balanced the ketchup and brown sugar nicely. I will definitely use this one again.”

View Recipe

Save

15 Memorable Meatloaf Recipes

06
of 10

Aunt Judi's Easter Pineapple Raisin Sauce

lutzflcat

"One of my must-haves with ham, especially at Easter," says Allrecipes member raesive. "This is the recipe I grew up with. My aunt would make it every year. A nice sweet accent!"

View Recipe

Save

07
of 10

Art's Southern-Style Chocolate Gravy

"This recipe is spot on, and makes a great tasting chocolate gravy," says reviewer Cheryl. "Great on home made biscuits or ice cream."

View Recipe

Save

The Simple Recipe My Granny Has Made Every Weekend for Decades

08
of 10

Monkey Sauce

getty

“Monkey sauce is a tangy hodgepodge of condiments you probably already have in your refrigerator,” says Food Writer Terri Peters. Most versions include a chopped onion, minced garlic, ketchup, chutney, Worcestershire sauce, and a splash of vinegar. The result is downright delicious.

View Recipe

15 Stuffed Burger Recipes

09
of 10

Grandmother B's Sauce for Ham

“Delicious! Didn’t change a thing,” says reviewer pam st. “Great combination of flavors. Sweet but tangy. Really compliments baked ham.”

View Recipe

Save

19 Best Side Dishes to Serve With Ham All Year Long

10
of 10

Idaho Fry Sauce

Dotdash Meredith Food Studios

“What is it? Fry sauce is commonly found in Utah, southern Idaho, and rural Oregon,” says Allrecipes member Heather. “I am trying to spread the word! This is an amazing recipe and after tasting this, you will never again settle for plain ketchup with fries.”

View Recipe

Save

I Tested 5 Different Frozen French Fries and This Is the Brand I’ll Buy From Now On

More Inspiration